In 1881 Fayetteville, Arkansas was a small village, and one with a reputation of being as wild as any town “out west.”
Much of Fayetteville was burned by soldiers on both sides during the Civil War. But the beginnings of this tale go back before the war. Three brothers John, George and James Reed, sons of Richard Reed, all natives of the county, were known to be industrious and respected. John went off to war and returned a quiet man when sober but a bully when drunk. After defying authorities on more than one occasion, he became known as a bad man.
That reputation would be strained to the breaking point when Sheriff John R. Sorrell arrested a close friend of the Reeds in February of 1879. Rutherford failed to pay his bond and so the law was on the verge of jailing him when good friend John Reed arrived. In his bully phase, he demanded his friend’s release, yet refused to come up with his bail.
The jailer opened the cell door to throw the prisoner in and Reed hit him on the head with a bottle of brandy. Deputy Sheriff Sorrell shot Reed and was arrested and charged with homicide. At his trial he was set free. John’s brother George swore he’d avenge John’s subsequent death, but since George wasn’t of the same pursuasion as his wilder brother John, no one thought much of it.
It was well known that he feared Marshal Stirman, going so far as to beg him not to shoot him if he ever got in trouble. Of course, Stirman wouldn’t make such a promise, so Reed later drew down on the Marshal while mounted and was promptly dragged off his horse and beaten by Stirman. Nothing more came of this, so everyone forgot about Reed’s promise to avenge the death of his brother. But this wouldn’t be the end of this fracas. Some people just don’t forget when they think they’ve been wronged.
Marshal Stirman retired in 1881 and was replaced by William Patton, whereupon George told friends he was going to try out the new marshal. Obviously he didn’t fear Patton like he had Stirman. So one day he rode into town and deliberately picked a fight with Patton, drew on him and was shot and killed by the marshal who was promptly acquitted of any charges. Now we have two Reed boys killed and friends and family up in arms demanding someone be punished. They became so vocal about it that Patton feared for his life.
Patton believed he would be shot down on the street and did everything he could think of to prevent it. But on a dark Saturday night, about 9 o’clock, July 2, 1881, while Patton and his deputy John Mount were talking on the public square, shots came out of the dark and both were instantly killed. Though no one could ever prove who the assassins were, everyone was sure they were friends of Reed.
Thomas J. Churchill, Governor of Arkansas offered an award of $500 for the arrest and conviction of the assassins. No one was ever arrested.
Meanwhile, Mount’s family received an anonymous bundle of money and a note that he wasn’t meant to be killed. The killers were never identified.
In looking into Mount’s service record, he was the true hero of this piece. He served as a private in Co. G, 16th Arkansas Infantry from the fall of 1861 until the end of that brutal war in April, 1865. He enlisted at the age of 17, was captured at Port Hudson, Louisiana on July 9, 1863. After the war he married Catherine E. when he was 25 and she was 22. When he was killed he left behind his wife and four children, the youngest about one year old.
In those days a woman left in this situation had few choices, the best of which was to find another man to marry. Often it was a man who had been widowed himself and left with small children. Some women would find menial jobs they could do, such as taking in washing and ironing, cleaning houses, and the like. With smaller children and nothing resembling day care, they could not go out and find work, scarce as it was for women.In 1903, after moving closer to her brother for support, Catherine applied for a widow’s pension on the basis of her husband’s service in the army of the Confederate States. Her application was approved.
In those days pensions ranged from $10 a month to $40, scarcely any more. It was not only men who were heroes in the old west, but the women who supported them, bore their children and kept a good home. And like Catherine, who carried on when widowed.